A 3×4 downspout moves about twice the water of a 2×3 and clogs far less. That makes it the right choice on large roof planes and on any downspout that jams every fall. It is not always the right fix. A long run that overflows at the far end needs another downspout more than a bigger one, and a gutter full of leaves needs neither.
The two sizes compared
| 2×3 | 3×4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Opening | 6 square inches | 12 square inches |
| Roof area it drains | About 600 sq ft | About 1,200 sq ft |
| Clogs | More easily, at the elbows | Passes most leaves and seeds |
| Usual pairing | 5-inch gutters on smaller planes | 6-inch gutters, or 5-inch on large planes |
| Looks | Slimmer against the wall | Noticeably wider on a narrow corner |
The capacity figures come from the rule the trade uses, 1 square inch of downspout opening for every 100 square feet of roof. A 3×4 has exactly twice the opening of a 2×3, so it drains twice the roof.
Bigger, another, or guards?
Each fixes a different problem, which is why people who buy the wrong one are still standing in the rain watching water spill.
| What is happening | Better fix |
|---|---|
| The downspout clogs every fall | Bigger downspout |
| The far end of a long run overflows in hard rain | Another downspout |
| A waterfall at one inside corner under a valley | Another downspout at the corner |
| The gutter fills with leaves between cleanings | Guards, then maybe a bigger downspout |
| Water floods the gutter along its whole length with clear outlets | Bigger gutter, with 3×4 downspouts |
| The downspout runs clear but the ground floods below it | The buried line or the discharge, not the downspout |
When a bigger downspout is the answer
Clogging is the most common reason to upsize. Sioux Falls trees drop maple seeds in spring and leaves in fall, and the tight elbows of a 2×3 are where they jam. A 3×4 passes most of what gets past the outlet, so a downspout that clogs every October often stops once it is swapped.
The other reason is roof area. A 2×3 is rated for about 600 square feet. A single roof plane on a two-story house can easily be more, and on a 6-inch gutter a 2×3 becomes the bottleneck of the whole system.
One catch: the outlet has to change too. A 3×4 downspout needs a 3×4 outlet cut into the gutter floor. A big pipe hung under a small hole drains no faster than the hole.
Get a free quote for your house
When another downspout is the answer
Plan on one downspout for every 30 to 40 feet of gutter. The reason is distance as much as volume: water has to travel the length of the run to reach an outlet, and a gutter only falls 1/16 inch per foot, so on a long run the water at the far end moves slowly and piles up.
Take a 57-foot run with one downspout at one end. In a hard rain the far end is 57 feet from the only way out, and it spills. Put a downspout at each end, with the gutter high in the middle and falling both ways, and no water travels more than about 28 feet. The same gutter stops overflowing without getting any bigger.
Valleys and upper roofs change the count too. A roof valley can deliver about 30 gallons a minute to a few feet of gutter at the rainfall rate Sioux Falls gutters are sized for, so the corner under one usually earns an outlet of its own. An upper roof whose downspout empties onto a lower roof sends all of its water into a short stretch of the lower gutter. Either route that downspout down past the lower roof, or count its roof area into the lower gutter’s load when sizing.
Placement and looks
Downspouts go at corners where they can, because corners are where they are least noticeable and where the water can be carried away from the house most easily. Keep them away from doors and walks, where the discharge becomes ice in winter, and away from the spot where the lawn slopes back toward the foundation.
A 3×4 is noticeably wider than a 2×3. On a broad wall nobody sees the difference. On a narrow corner by the front door, some homeowners keep a 2×3 there and put the 3×4 on the back of the house, which is a reasonable trade if that front roof plane is small.
When it is not the downspout at all
If water runs cleanly out of the bottom of the downspout and still floods the ground, the downspout is fine. The problem is where it discharges, or a buried line that has clogged or frozen. A bigger downspout on a blocked underground pipe just fills the pipe faster. Where the water can legally go in each town is a separate question from how fast it comes down.
Questions about downspout size and count
How much more water does a 3×4 downspout move than a 2×3?
About twice as much. A 2×3 has 6 square inches of opening and a 3×4 has 12, and the trade rule of 1 square inch per 100 square feet of roof rates them at about 600 and 1,200 square feet.
Do bigger downspouts clog less?
Yes, noticeably. Maple seeds, oak leaves and shingle grit that jam a 2×3 elbow tend to pass through a 3×4. It is often the cheapest fix for a downspout that clogs every fall.
How many downspouts does a house need?
Plan on one for every 30 to 40 feet of gutter, and more where a valley or an upper roof dumps water into one spot. The roof area each one drains matters more than the count.
Is another downspout better than a bigger one?
When the problem is one end of a long run overflowing, yes: a second outlet halves the distance water has to travel. When the problem is a downspout that keeps clogging, a bigger one fixes it and a second one does not.
Should every downspout be upgraded to 3×4?
Not necessarily. Upgrade the ones draining large roof planes, the ones under valleys and the ones that clog. A 2×3 on a short run over a porch roof is doing its job.
Will a 3×4 downspout fit my existing gutter?
It needs a matching 3×4 outlet cut into the gutter, not just a bigger pipe below it. Ask whether the outlet is being changed, because a large downspout under a small outlet drains no faster.
Get a quote
Tell us about the job, with a photo of the downspout that is giving trouble, and a local gutter contractor will call, text or email to set up a visit. The quote is free.
Related
- 5-inch vs 6-inch gutters
- Why gutters overflow
- What gutter guards cost, and whether they pay back